Weight Placement

dj10

dj10

New member
To the ITAC:
I hope I'm not alone on this, I think it's time to be able to use the passanger side for weight placement instead the foot well area as now written. I believe this would help front wheel drive as well as rear wheel drives. If any proposals have been sumitted please get them pushed through.
 
jd10, if I was asking the ITAC or CRB for support I would include my name & SCCA member number within the post. Better yet, I would send a letter to the ITAC & CRB. ;)
 
I could be wrong on this (I wish I had saved my old GCRs over the years) but I think that the ballast rule may have pre-dated the allowance to remove the passenger seat so forward of the seat was the logical location. I certainly don't think it was meant to favor or penalize any particular car configuration. Does it?

I carry a lot of ballast and I would like to move it aft as much as possible but why should the SCCA care? Unless the rule is patently unfair to some cars, why the change? I don't really care but I have to point out that the rules are not supposed to be changed just to make all cars theoretically faster across the board. Competitively, that just cancels out and we are right back where we started.
 
Bill, that's a great point, and one to remember in all rules discussions.

However, the item did come up some time ago, and as far as I know, it was on the way to becoming changed to allow the use of the seat mount area, or something along those lines. But for some reason, it hasn't been turned down, approved or tabled. So it is being looked into.

I imagine we should have some feedback on it in the near future.
 
Bill, that's a great point, and one to remember in all rules discussions.

However, the item did come up some time ago, and as far as I know, it was on the way to becoming changed to allow the use of the seat mount area, or something along those lines. But for some reason, it hasn't been turned down, approved or tabled. So it is being looked into.

I imagine we should have some feedback on it in the near future.
[/b]
Click to expand...

sure would be nice if they approved it.....just in case a certain car is forced to put a significant amount of lead in a legal location...... B)
 
Cripes if you have the luxury of being able to add weight, there are lots of ways to do so without ballast.

Spare tires, stainless steel exhaust systems, accusumps, more cage trube--down low--all come to mind.

Cheers.
 
sure would be nice if they approved it.....just in case a certain car is forced to put a significant amount of lead in a legal location...... B)
[/b]
Click to expand...

Marshall, this is why I posted this ;). Now everyone get off your asses and email CRB to approve what they have ad sitting on there plate for some time. :D I believe this is fair for everyone who has to carry weight.
 
Guys, why so cryptic? Just come out and say what you mean. Is it not possible to put lead in the legal location in that certain car now? If it is, then there is no reason to change the rule. But if there are cars that are indeed penalized by the current rule I will support the change.

FWIW I run w/ the spare tire, a full tank of gas, and at least 50# of weight.
 
Bill, for me for example, it would be easier (and in my view safer) to run the lead where the seat was as this area is flat. The floor in the footwell is sloped and it is harder to mount my 50 lbs in that area. I'm probably border line illegal at the moment, as the weight is JUST forward of where the original passenger seat rails end.

I'm in favor of this as well. If you write, you may add my SCCA No. (304971).

Thanks guys.
 
Guys, why so cryptic? Just come out and say what you mean. Is it not possible to put lead in the legal location in that certain car now? If it is, then there is no reason to change the rule. But if there are cars that are indeed penalized by the current rule I will support the change.

FWIW I run w/ the spare tire, a full tank of gas, and at least 50# of weight.
[/b]
Click to expand...

what we mean? we would like the rule changed to allow placement of ballast somewhere other than just the footwell. my guess is that this would help more than just us. it would be a bunch easier to use some of the factory seat mounting locations for ballast rather than the sheet metal floor of the footwell. i would guess the original rule writers were not thinking 300lbs of ballast would be needed.

why? well, the thought of stacking (7) 45lb plates in the footwell just doesn't sound good... :P

i already have 40lbs there and i run with a full tank of gas.
 
Mounting 300lbs in a single place to the floor anywhere inside the car would scare me. Go do a search in the tech section and read the thread that links to some posts from one of the World Challenge builders. He talks about a 30lb brick deforming the floorpan 90 degrees in a wreck. Imagine what 300 would do.

I'd actually like to see the ballast mounting rule opened up more to allow something like mounting anywhere to the passenger compartment floor. I'm putting on my flame suit since I'll now be accused of commiting rules sacrilige, but if you're gonna add a lot of weight to cars then I think they should be given more options on how to mount it. Please don't talk about stainless exhausts, accusumps, and whatever else could be added for weight. Last time I checked that stuff cost a lot more money than a plain old chunk of lead or steel.

I already have my 100lbs bolted to my passenger footwell (and tethered to the roll cage). I hope to remove a lot of that over time as I beef up the cage and do other things, but putting in a 100lbs of ballast was the easiest and cheapest thing to do given that I had less than a month to add weight before my first race. Being able to mount the ballast in a different location might have made things easier. It was a pain in the ass putting the ballast in the passenger footwell.

David
 
Mounting 300lbs in a single place to the floor anywhere inside the car would scare me. Go do a search in the tech section and read the thread that links to some posts from one of the World Challenge builders. He talks about a 30lb brick deforming the floorpan 90 degrees in a wreck. Imagine what 300 would do.

I'd actually like to see the ballast mounting rule opened up more to allow something like mounting anywhere to the passenger compartment floor. I'm putting on my flame suit since I'll now be accused of commiting rules sacrilige, but if you're gonna add a lot of weight to cars then I think they should be given more options on how to mount it. Please don't talk about stainless exhausts, accusumps, and whatever else could be added for weight. Last time I checked that stuff cost a lot more money than a plain old chunk of lead or steel.

I already have my 100lbs bolted to my passenger footwell (and tethered to the roll cage). I hope to remove a lot of that over time as I beef up the cage and do other things, but putting in a 100lbs of ballast was the easiest and cheapest thing to do given that I had less than a month to add weight before my first race. Being able to mount the ballast in a different location might have made things easier. It was a pain in the ass putting the ballast in the passenger footwell.

David
[/b]
Click to expand...

[email protected]
tell them it's on their plate.
 
Please don't talk about stainless exhausts, accusumps, and whatever else could be added for weight. Last time I checked that stuff cost a lot more money than a plain old chunk of lead or steel.

David while I do not have a strong opinion on the ballast mounting option this statement kind of got to me. count yourself lucky. Adding weight in this manner is a whole lot cheaper that what those of us are going thru who are trying to get to a weight that is almost imposible.

it is a lot cheaper to add weight than to add light.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
 
Dickita has seen the light about adding light, LOL

Not only that, (removing weight is very tough), but you have to take it where you cn find it. If you can find it, it is often in a spot that hurts balance. Ading weight allows you to actually balance the car better...if you're creative, and while this isn't a total engineering category like Prod and GT, it sin't SS either.
 
David while I do not have a strong opinion on the ballast mounting option this statement kind of got to me. count yourself lucky. Adding weight in this manner is a whole lot cheaper that what those of us are going thru who are trying to get to a weight that is almost imposible.

it is a lot cheaper to add weight than to add light.[/b]
Click to expand...

Dick, I'm not sure anyone is disputing that adding weight can be cheaper / easier for many cars. I believe the point was referring to how / where weight is added. I.e. adding a 25 lb plate further towards the rear vs. adding "additional support bars to an existing cage".
 
It would be much safer to allow weight to be anywhere in the passenger side floor area. It would also give the cars that get weight a chance to still have good chasis balance. The weight is to slow acceleration and reduce corner and brake ability--not kill the balance all together. It also lets us use the strong area of the seat mounts to better secure the blocks. We should also be allowed to tie the weight box to the passenger side cage if needed. A drop down mount like we use for the driver seat would be very safe and offer no real stiffening to the chasis. just an opinion. My letter will go out this week.
 
Oh yea? I bolted 90# of lead to the pass footwell area with beefy brackets, a pass seat and a spare tire...i still need 1/2 tank to make weight. I havent had the time to weld cage pieces in good locations or the funds to buy accusumps cool suits etc...The idea of all that lead coming out does go thru my mind though...i just hope the lead doesnt! :P I did write an email requesting the pass seat bracket area for lead as it would definitely be safer as the seat can hold a fat passenger and not fly off its mounts...seems logical and safe...
 
I don't think there is anything in the rules that prevent putting factory parts back in the car. I am sure the E36 came with a nice heavy factory option electric leathe seat. The down side to making location free is that weight no longer is a equalizer. on some cars free location will make the car better.
 
Free location is a little much...just with in the pass seat mounting bracket holes would be sufficient. The free part comes with roll cage and spare tire B)
 
The simple way is my method. Just get lazy in the off season, don't work out, eat and drink way too much, and you can get there easy...and in the seat area. I used to run right at the exact weight...now I'm 30 lbs over. Bad part is I had to get a new driver's suit for my fat butt! However, the "ballast" is right where I needed it!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top